Social learning in teacher professional development for environmental and sustainability education

Cincera, Jan, Goldman, Daphne, & Válková, Tereza. (2026). Social learning in teacher professional development for environmental and sustainability education. Teacher Development, 30(1), 1-21,. 10.1080/13664530.2025.2490735

A familiar problem: one enthusiastic teacher goes on a training course, comes back full of ideas, and meets colleagues who aren't interested. In the Czech Republic, earlier training courses ran into exactly this kind of resistance. A national survey found that only about half of teachers had a team at their school that planned environmental education together. The Masters of Peer Support program was designed to tackle this by training teachers in teams within their own schools.

How the program worked.

  • Three Czech environmental education centers (SEVER, TEREZA and Lipka) ran Masters of Peer Support from 2017 to 2020. It reached 64 elementary schools over four two-year rounds.
  • Its aim was to help teachers build students' scientific literacy: their ability to ask questions, investigate and think like scientists, mostly through outdoor learning.
  • In each school, one teacher acted as team leader (the program called this role "mentor") for three to ten colleagues.
  • Each team chose goals that fit its school, met regularly, planned activities and tracked progress. Outside coaches from the centers made sure the goals stayed focused on environmental learning.
  • Coaches helped team leaders clarify goals, run their teams and find teaching methods. They visited schools and kept in regular contact. The centers also ran three meetings and a summer school for team leaders.
  • Each team produced something concrete. Examples included a school-wide project day about water, a new approach to outdoor field trips, investigation projects in city parks, and new habitats for insects.
  • Teams taught their new units at the end. Coaches and teachers from other schools came to watch, and the team then reviewed how it went.

How the study worked. The researchers studied the first round, in 24 schools.

  • Before the program, 87 teachers and 24 team leaders described what they hoped to gain.
  • Two months after it ended, 44 teachers and 15 team leaders described what they had changed in their teaching.
  • In five schools, the researchers held two group discussions with 26 teachers and interviewed each team leader twice.
  • Nine coaches answered written questions, and four program managers were interviewed three times each.
  • The researchers looked for common themes across all of this.

The program was built on three ideas about how adults learn:

  • Transformative learning changes the assumptions people hold about how things should be done. It often starts with a "disorienting dilemma," an experience that unsettles those assumptions, followed by reflection, new perspectives and action.
  • Social learning happens in a group, as people compare their ideas and values.
  • Organizational learning happens when what individuals learn spreads through a whole school or organization.

What they found:

The main finding is that the program sparked transformative learning in a group setting. Teachers changed how they taught, and schools and centers began learning as organizations. The researchers called the central experience "opening."

  1. Freedom unsettled teachers at first, then opened new ways of teaching. Some teachers and team leaders were confused by the program's open structure and worried about the time it would take. As work went on, they found the freedom let them experiment and break old habits. One teacher said it let the team "bloom." The authors see this early unease as a disorienting dilemma that led to reflection and new action.
  2. Teachers changed how they taught by working together. Most teachers reported positive changes:
    • Many began teaching in pairs or small teams.
    • Some combined subjects, such as language and science, or planned joint lessons for students of different ages.
    • Teachers gave each other honest feedback. One primary teacher described how a high school colleague helped her put her science lesson in a clearer order, while he learned how to speak with young children.
    • The authors say this shows group learning and personal change feeding each other.
  3. Teachers' motivation returned, boosted by their students. Teachers who had taught the same way for years said they felt "hooked" again. They saw students more motivated and enthusiastic, and some children showed strengths that had not come out before.
  4. Change began to spread through schools, but met limits.
    • Collaboration and mutual feedback became more common, which the authors see as first steps toward whole-school change.
    • Principals often allowed the work but gave little active support.
    • Some colleagues outside the teams resisted. One teacher tried to spread investigation-based lessons across the school but found colleagues saw the method as too demanding.
    • Planning and teaching new units also took a lot of time.
  5. Team leaders and organizers had to learn too.
    • Team leaders had to manage group dynamics and keep colleagues working together, which was new to them.
    • Many coaches realized they were not prepared to guide teams rather than direct them. They learned on the job and said they should have had training first.
    • The three centers moved from working separately to sharing methods openly, and began trying to work more as teams within their own organizations.

The authors offer three further interpretations. Teachers' practice changed more readily than their deeper beliefs. Because only a few teachers per school took part, the majority who kept the old approach slowed wider change. And students experienced the changes without helping to shape them. They also note a tension: managers sometimes guided teams toward their own expertise in outdoor learning, which left some teachers unsure how much freedom they really had. They conclude that peer support is essential for this kind of learning, that the emotional side of change needs care, and that everyone running the program learns alongside the teachers.

What this means for your practice:

Build a team, not a lone champion. Teams within schools were the heart of this program, and most teachers reported changes in their teaching. Bring together a small group in one school with one teacher leading. Agree on one goal that fits your school, meet regularly and aim for something concrete, such as a new unit or project day.

Give freedom, with clear limits. Freedom to set their own goals drove teachers' learning, but some were unsure where the boundaries lay. The researchers recommend balancing choice with clear guidance.

Expect and support the emotional ride. Teachers moved from fear to enthusiasm. The researchers recommend that people running programs facilitate this with care. Tell teams early that confusion is normal, and celebrate their projects when they are finished.

Teach in pairs and give feedback. Paired teaching and honest peer feedback were among the most common changes teachers reported. Pair teachers from different subjects or grade levels and visit each other's lessons.

Win real support from principals. Limited support from school leaders was a major barrier to deeper change. The researchers recommend involving school leadership more fully. Ask early for time, interest and visible backing, not just permission.

Plan for colleagues outside the team. Resistance from uninvolved staff slowed whole-school change. The paper does not test solutions, but it shows this needs attention from the start.

Prepare your coaches. Coaches struggled to guide rather than direct. If you run a program like this, the researchers recommend training coaches in group facilitation before they begin.

Bring students in. The researchers suggest making students active partners in shaping the changes, since they were left out of this program.

RETURN TO EDUCATOR TRAINING EERESEARCH COLLECTION 

The Bottom Line

The researchers followed the program's first two-year round in 24 Czech elementary schools, gathering views from teachers, team leaders, coaches and managers. Their main argument is that training built around teams of teachers who learn together, and who are free to set their own goals, can change how teachers teach and begin change across a whole school. Teachers moved from early confusion and fear to enthusiasm. The authors call this "opening": feeling freed from old habits and ready to try something new. Many teachers began teaching in pairs, combining subjects and giving each other honest feedback, and many said their motivation to teach returned. Deeper change across whole schools was held back by limited time, weak support from principals and resistance from colleagues outside the teams. The organizers had to learn new skills too. For educators, the study shows that peer learning can transform teaching when it has leadership backing and skilled facilitation.