Beyond traditional teacher professional development: Innovations in teacher professional learning in environmental and sustainability education

Ernst, Julie, Erickson, Deanna, Burgess, Eva, & Feldbrugge, Ryan. (2020). Beyond Traditional Teacher Professional Development: Innovations in Teacher Professional Learning in Environmental and Sustainability Education. Journal of Sustainability Education.

Teachers are asked to do a great deal, often under pressure to raise test scores. Since the 1990s, critics have pointed out that environmental education training relies on "one-shot," one-size-fits-all workshops focused on content. These workshops rarely help teachers keep using their local environment for learning. The authors argue that sustainability education asks students to think in systems, collaborate and act, so teachers need training that works the same way.

To show what that looks like, the authors describe Rivers2Lake, a program Deanna Erickson started in 2012 with many partners. It is based at the Lake Superior National Estuarine Research Reserve, a protected area where the St. Louis River meets Lake Superior, used for research and education. The reserve is run by the University of Wisconsin–Madison Division of Extension and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). A second staff member works at the Superior Rivers Watershed Association. Lake Superior, also called Gichigami, lies within the homeland of the Anishinaabe (Ojibwe) people. Partnerships with Anishinaabe-led groups shape the program and center traditional ways of life and Indigenous knowledge. The authors chose Rivers2Lake because earlier evaluations, reported in the article, found that students in these teachers' classes:

  • better understood the Great Lakes
  • developed a stronger sense of place and commitment to local stewardship
  • showed improved learning and engagement

How the program works:

  • Summer Institute. Each year opens with this four-day trip for 12 teachers and staff. They travel from the river's headwaters in northeastern Minnesota to the Wisconsin shore of Lake Superior. Along the way they meet experts, learn the region's environmental and human history, run water quality investigations, practice outdoor teaching skills and plan their year.
  • Mentoring. During the school year, mentors from the reserve and the watershed association help each teacher build lessons and field trips around real research and stewardship projects, matched to their students and standards. Mentors meet teachers on a set schedule and co-teach lessons.
  • Winter Symposium. This one-day gathering takes place six months after the Summer Institute.

The authors look at the program through three "learning processes" that a UNESCO expert review linked to strong sustainability learning:

  1. Dialogue and collaboration. Real two-way exchange in which learners, not the trainer, shape the conversation and build shared understanding.
  2. Engaging the whole system. Seeing each teacher as part of nested circles (self, classroom, school, community and landscape) and asking teachers about the real limits they face.
  3. Active, hands-on learning. Teachers experience the same hands-on methods they are asked to use with students.

What they found:

The main finding is that ongoing, mentored, place-based professional learning built on these three processes changes teachers' practice and helps them keep it going.

  1. Mentoring turns collaboration into lasting support. Mentoring in Rivers2Lake runs both ways:
    • Teachers bring knowledge of their students, curriculum and school.
    • Mentors bring outdoor and place-based teaching skills, and act as "educational companions" rather than evaluators.
    • Meetings are booked ahead, with reminders, and leave room for personal support as well as planning.
    • Mentors find lesson resources, stewardship activities, field sites and local texts, plus real research and land management questions that become student investigations. Some of these questions involve competing uses and values.
    • The authors report that this ongoing dialogue helps teachers get past practical, curriculum and administrative barriers.
  2. Working with the whole system keeps change going.
    • Mentors co-teach in classrooms. Over a year, the authors observed teachers and students move from feeling new and unsure outdoors to showing real expertise to their school and community.
    • Mentors also offer outdoor experiences and short training sessions to teachers who are not in the program, to build a schoolwide culture that values this kind of learning.
    • They talk regularly with principals and curriculum staff and share progress with school boards. The authors report that support for the program grew as a result.
    • Teachers join a wider network of scientists, land managers, educators and cultural practitioners, which the authors found eased their sense of being alone in making change.
  3. Hands-on learning changes how teachers think about teaching, not just what they do.
    • The Summer Institute and Winter Symposium immerse teachers in the landscape. The Winter Symposium also gives teachers tools for teaching outdoors in subzero cold and deep snow.
    • The authors see the last two months of the school year as the peak, when warmer weather and less academic pressure give teachers room to create.
    • One fifth-grade teacher's class shows what a year-long focus can build. Her students visited Wisconsin Point, a nearby beach important to the community, throughout the year and studied its plants and wildlife. In May they planted cedar trees with an Anishinaabe elder, at a spot where he remembered cedars growing in his youth. They also explored by canoe and made art on site.
    • The teacher later said the year strengthened her commitment to teaching outdoors.

The authors name several barriers:

  • pressure from standardized tests
  • narrow ideas of student achievement
  • the expectations of administrators, parents and community members
  • everyday logistics

Beyond this case, they draw three conclusions. First, working deeply with a small group may look less impressive from outside but produces more lasting results, so programs should be judged differently. Second, mentoring creates ripple effects as teachers influence their wider communities. Third, grounding teaching in the landscape right outside the door helps programs last.

What this means for your practice:

Plan for a year, not a day. The authors' central recommendation is to replace one-off workshops with ongoing support for a small group. If you run teacher training, consider fewer teachers with deeper, year-long contact, and measure success by lasting change rather than attendance.

Make mentoring two-way and dependable. Rivers2Lake's mentoring is what the authors credit with helping teachers past real barriers. Book check-ins ahead, send reminders, treat teachers as the experts on their students, and co-teach early lessons so teachers can try new methods with backup.

Ask teachers what limits them. The authors argue that training must fit teachers' real constraints, such as tests, administrators and timetables. Ask about these at the start and plan around them.

Connect teachers to local knowledge. Teachers felt less alone once they joined a network of scientists, land managers, cultural practitioners and elders. Introduce teachers to people in your own area and encourage them to treat that network as theirs.

Work with the school around the teacher. Talking with principals and school boards, and inviting other teachers in, increased support for Rivers2Lake. Build these relationships into your program from the start.

Use the rhythm of the year. A mid-year gathering let teachers share problems and learn winter skills, and the biggest projects came together in spring. The Wisconsin Point project is one teacher's example rather than a tested model, but it shows what a long focus on one place can grow into.

Train the way you want teachers to teach. The authors argue that training should model the outdoor, hands-on, reflective methods teachers will use with students.

RETURN TO THE EDUCATOR TRAINING EERESEARCH COLLECTION 

The Bottom Line

The authors examined how Rivers2Lake, a year-long teacher program on Lake Superior, supports teachers. Their main argument is that traditional one-off workshops cannot prepare teachers for environmental and sustainability education. They say training should instead become ongoing professional learning, built on three approaches: real collaboration and dialogue, engaging the whole system around a teacher, and active, hands-on learning. Rivers2Lake shows how this can work. A small group of teachers spends four days exploring the watershed, then works all year with a mentor who plans and co-teaches alongside them. Mentors also build links with principals, other teachers, scientists, land managers and Anishinaabe (Ojibwe) leaders and elders. The authors observed teachers growing from uncertain beginners into confident leaders of outdoor learning, with the biggest projects often coming together near the end of the school year. For educators, the lesson is that deep, sustained support for a few teachers can create more lasting change than brief contact with many.