Practice change in environmental education: Lessons from professional development

Li, Yue, & Krasny, Marianne E. (2019). Practice change in environmental education: lessons from professional development programs. ENVIRON EDUC RES, 25(7), 1119-1136,. 10.1080/13504622.2018.1540033

Environmental educators keep having to adapt to new issues and new audiences, such as growing numbers of young people in cities. Training is meant to help. But most research on teacher training measures confidence, knowledge or intentions, not whether educators actually do anything differently. Yue Li and Marianne Krasny at Cornell University wanted a clearer way to see real change in practice.

All three programs in this study were part of Expanding Capacity in Environmental Education (EECapacity). This five-year effort was funded by the US Environmental Protection Agency and ran across the US, Canada and Mexico. It aimed to create ways for environmental educators to swap ideas and resources with youth development professionals. Youth development professionals run programs that help young people build skills and confidence, sometimes through environmental activities such as community gardening. The thinking behind EECapacity was that bringing together people with different backgrounds and ways of working sparks new practice.

The three programs (all ran in 2014):

  • Pennsylvania State Consortium. 27 environmental educators and youth development professionals from nature centers, state agencies, schools, parks and youth organizations. They met through face-to-face workshops, monthly webinars and Facebook discussions, led by one co-leader from each field. The goal was to bring youth development professionals into the state's environmental education leadership. There were no set assignments.
  • Online learning community. 43 educators and community leaders from urban schools, afterschool programs, community and faith groups, and zoos. They used online resources, webinars and a Facebook group, and wrote chapters in small groups for a free eBook called Urban Environmental Education.
  • Community climate education fellowship. 26 educators and community leaders. They attended two multi-day workshops, used a Facebook group, ran their own climate education projects in schools, aquariums and community groups, and later co-wrote an eBook.

How the study worked. The researchers drew on practice theory, which looks at a working routine as a set of connected parts. They defined six parts of environmental education practice:

  • Goals: for example, changing environmental behavior, building community or fostering a sense of place.
  • Audiences: ages and groups served.
  • Settings: for example, schools, parks or community gardens.
  • Activities: for example, outdoor lessons, art or media projects.
  • Resources: materials and people to call on.
  • Ideas.

They counted adding new parts as practice innovation. Surveys asked educators to tick which goals, audiences, settings and activities their programs included, both before and after the training, so the researchers could count changes. The Pennsylvania group was surveyed only afterward. Surveys also asked educators to rate how much each part had changed, on a scale from "not at all" to "totally," and to describe the changes. The researchers also interviewed educators from two programs and read the fellows' project reports.

What they found:

The main finding is that in all three programs educators adopted new resources and ideas, while changes in other parts of practice depended on program design and on how much control educators had.

  1. New resources and ideas spread in every program. Educators in all three programs rated their use of new resources and ideas from fellow educators higher than any other change. Resources included lesson materials and new contacts to call on. One community development professional said meeting environmental educators "got my wheels turning" about adding environmental work to her programs. The authors suggest resources and ideas are the easiest parts to adopt, and could lead to wider changes over time.
  2. Other changes matched how each program was designed.
    • Pennsylvania: educators added significantly more goals. Environmental educators added community-building work, and youth development professionals began planning environmental education. The authors link this to the program's focus on bringing the two fields together.
    • Online community: educators added significantly more activities, such as having students use social media to explore topics. Writing chapters pushed them to look up research, which made them more confident to use new ideas. The finished eBook also became a source of inspiration.
    • Fellowship: educators reached more teens and young adults, used more settings (such as community centers, churches and theaters) and added more activities (such as art, media and visits to environmental facilities). Some began training other educators.
  3. Who and where were hardest to change. Educators changed their audiences and settings least, often because their school or organization decided these. Some refined their programs rather than adding to them. One educator dropped a goal so her students could take "baby steps" first. The authors stress that adding more parts is not automatically better.
  4. Group products were the clearest signs of new practice.
    • Two programs produced free eBooks that are still used.
    • The Pennsylvania program became a model for statewide training that links environmental and youth work.
    • Facebook groups that grew from the wider effort now have several thousand members who regularly swap resources.
    • The authors argue that new practice is easier to see in these shared products than in counts of individual change.
  5. Online learning worked about as well as meeting in person. The researchers saw no clear advantage for face-to-face programs. In the online program, small chapter-writing teams formed strong working ties without ever meeting.

What this means for your practice:

Make sharing the core of your training. Resources and ideas from peers were the change educators made most in every program. Build in time for people to swap materials, contacts and stories, and give them somewhere to keep sharing afterward, such as an online group.

Give the group something to make together. Writing a book chapter or running a project helped educators turn new ideas into new activities, and both books are still in use. Consider ending your training with a shared product.

Use online learning with a purpose. Online learning worked when it was built around small teams with a shared task. If people can't meet in person, organize them that way.

Mix fields. Bringing environmental educators and youth development professionals together led both groups to add new goals. Invite people from neighboring fields into your training.

Focus on what people can change. Educators rarely controlled their audiences or settings. Ask early which parts of their work they can change, and aim your training there, often activities and resources.

Judge success by what the group builds. The researchers recommend looking for change at the group level, such as shared products and lasting networks, alongside individual change. Remember that narrowing a program to make it clearer can be real progress too.

RETURN TO EDUCATOR TRAINING EERESEARCH COLLECTION

The Bottom Line

The researchers surveyed and interviewed educators from three programs, about 95 people in all, before and after the training. Their main argument is that breaking practice into parts (goals, audiences, settings, activities, resources and ideas) is a useful way to see what professional development changes. They also argue that new practice often shows most clearly in what a group creates together. In all three programs, educators began using new resources and ideas from one another. Other changes depended on how each program was designed: one group added new goals, while others added new activities, audiences and settings. Educators changed who they taught and where least often, usually because their employer decided those things. Two groups wrote shared books, and one became a model for a statewide network. Online programs built around a shared project worked about as well as face-to-face ones. For trainers, the lesson is that peer sharing and joint projects drive new practice.