People do not judge risks by facts alone. Research on how people see risks shows that familiar or dramatic hazards often seem worse than slow, far-reaching problems that do more harm, and that experts and the public often rank risks differently. Before people change their behavior, they first need to recognize that a problem exists and is serious. The researchers wanted to know whether studying the environment at college helps people judge environmental risks more accurately. They also wanted to look beyond the problems the media cover most, to less familiar ones such as loss of biodiversity, loss of open space and water shortage.
The researchers surveyed 232 students at two colleges in Israel. Students were recruited through notices on bulletin boards and paid about $10 to complete a 25-to-30-minute online survey. Of these students:
- 103 studied environmental science, life sciences or geography. These programs covered environmental problems, their effects on nature and people, and how to tackle them, with a strong focus on Israel.
- 129 were in humanities and social science programs with no environmental content.
Students ranged in age from 19 to 65, partly because part-time students took part. The survey covered 13 problems. Ten came from a 2010 government report, written by leading experts, listing the country's most serious environmental problems:
- soil pollution;
- industrial air pollution;
- air pollution from traffic;
- pollution of water sources;
- pollution of the Mediterranean Sea;
- the falling level of the Dead Sea, which causes sinkholes;
- loss of green areas to building;
- loss of biodiversity;
- litter and waste in public places and nature;
- long-term drought and water shortage.
The researchers added three more. Earthquakes, a natural hazard, tested whether students treated human-caused and natural problems differently. Fires had been in the news at the time. Population growth is a main driver of the other problems but is rarely discussed in Israel.
For each problem, students answered seven questions about features known to shape how people see risks:
- how certain it is that the problem causes harm;
- whether it affects where they live;
- how immediate the danger is;
- how much it threatens them personally;
- how strongly it makes them feel sad, angry, afraid or disgusted;
- how predictable it is;
- how much the media report on it.
They then rated how serious each problem was overall. Finally, they ranked all 13 problems from most to least serious and explained why they chose their top one. This approach, common in research on how people perceive risk, also let the researchers map which problems students saw as similar or related.
What the researchers found:
- The main finding is that students in environment-related programs rated most problems as more serious, especially the complex ones. The biggest gap was for population growth. The two groups rated littering and earthquakes about the same. Fires were the only problem the other students rated as more serious. The survey ran in the fall of 2016, during a wave of wildfires and city fires in Israel, some suspected to be arson. The researchers explain that recent local events make a problem feel more serious.
- Students in environment-related programs saw problems as closer and more personal. They rated the problems as more certain, closer to where they live, more immediate, more personally threatening and more upsetting. The two groups rated media coverage about the same. The researchers note that problems with delayed, abstract or complex effects felt less relevant "here and now" to students without an environmental background.
- In both groups, certainty and feelings drove judgments of seriousness. Of the seven features, only two predicted how serious students judged a problem to be: how sure they were that it causes harm, and how strong their negative feelings about it were. Both mattered equally in both groups. The researchers see certainty as reflecting careful, reasoned thinking and feelings as reflecting gut reactions. Environmental study raised both, but did not change how much each one counted.
- Students in environment-related programs saw problems as connected. On the researchers' maps, these students placed biodiversity loss and population growth close to the cluster of pollution problems. Students in other programs placed them far away from the rest. The researchers read this as a better grasp of how pollution and littering feed into biodiversity loss, and of population growth as a driver of many problems.
- The groups agreed on the top problems but differed below them. Both groups ranked water, air, soil and sea pollution near the top. Students in environment-related programs ranked loss of biodiversity, loss of open space and population growth higher, and fires and earthquakes lower.
- Students explained their choices in different ways.
- About two-thirds of students in other programs focused on direct harm to people or to themselves. One wrote that air pollution was worst because we cannot live without clean air.
- About 60% of students in environment-related programs took a whole-system view, describing chain reactions, harm to other living things or wide-ranging effects. One explained that air pollution harms people and other organisms, and spreads because air moves.
- About 1 in 5 in each group focused on whether a problem could be solved. Students in environment-related programs weighed the practicality of different solutions in more detail.
The researchers stress that the survey cannot show whether the programs caused these differences, or whether students who already cared about the environment chose these programs. They argue that at least part of the difference comes from skills learned during study.
What this means for your practice:
- Teach how problems connect. Students in environment-related programs linked problems together and reasoned about whole systems, while other students saw problems in isolation. The researchers argue that this kind of systems thinking is something environmental education can build. One way to practice it is to trace a problem's chain of effects. One student, for example, explained that losing open space leaves no room for waste, so factories and people end up polluting soil and sea.
- Bring quieter problems into view. The biggest differences between the groups were for slow, wide-reaching problems such as loss of biodiversity and of open space. Give these attention alongside pollution, and help learners see how they touch everyday life.
- Work with both facts and feelings. How certain harm seemed and how upsetting a problem felt drove students' judgments in both groups. Clear evidence of harm and chances to connect emotionally with a problem both shape how seriously learners take it.
- Use recent events as a hook, then widen the view. Fires in the news made fires seem more serious to students without an environmental background. A recent local event can open a discussion, followed by comparison with longer-term problems.
- Ask learners to rank and explain. Students' written reasons showed differences in thinking, people-centered or whole-system, that their ratings alone did not. A simple "rank and explain why" task shows how your learners are reasoning.
- Present risk as having several parts. The researchers suggest teaching risk as a mix of likelihood, severity, uncertainty and consequences, shaped by both knowledge and values, and linking it to decisions in students' own lives. They recommend this for environmental and non-environmental courses alike. They also suggest that instructors learn how people perceive risks, to understand their students' thinking.
RETURN TO RISK AND ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION
The Bottom Line
The researchers surveyed 232 college students in Israel, some in environment-related programs and some in other programs, about 13 environmental problems facing the country. Their main argument is that environmental education is linked to a better-informed understanding of environmental risk, especially for complex problems that are easy to overlook. Students in environment-related programs rated most problems as more serious, more certain, closer to home and more personal. The biggest differences were for problems whose effects are wide-reaching, slow or hard to see, such as loss of biodiversity, loss of open space and population growth. These students also saw the problems as connected, and explained their choices in terms of whole natural and human systems. Students in other programs mostly focused on direct harm to people. In both groups, how certain the harm felt and how strong the feelings it stirred shaped how serious students judged a problem to be. For educators, this points to teaching how environmental problems connect, and attending to both facts and feelings.