Examining environmental learning experiences at an earth education summer camp

Cheeseman, Adam, & Wright, Tarah. (2019). Examining environmental learning experiences at an earth education summer camp. Environmental Education Research, 25, 375-387.

Why this matters and the context
Children spend less time in nature than they used to. In Nova Scotia, earlier research found that teachers struggle to fit environmental education into their lessons because of limited time, resources and curriculum demands. Out-of-school programs like summer camps help fill the gap.

Most camp evaluations check whether children reached goals set in advance, such as a gain in knowledge. That misses what children themselves find meaningful, including learning nobody planned. The researchers wanted to see camp through campers' eyes. They also wanted to test whether a familiar tool, the before-and-after survey, could be adapted to do this.

What the researchers did
Sunship Earth is a camp program used on three continents. It follows an approach called earth education, developed by Steve van Matre and the Institute for Earth Education. Earth education moves away from identifying species. Instead, it helps children understand big ecological ideas, build feelings of care for nature, and take responsible actions.

This study looked at one six-day residential Sunship Earth camp, run by the Halifax Regional Municipality's Adventure Earth Centre. The camp sits in a remote forest beside a large lake. About 40 children attend each session, with one staff member for every four campers. Most staff are former campers who are trained before they teach.

Each day, campers spent three to four hours in groups of 7 to 10 doing activities about seven ideas:

  • Energy flow: a relay race comparing how much energy is lost from plant-eaters to meat-eaters.
  • Cycles: a scavenger hunt for decomposers, the creatures that break down dead material.
  • Diversity: a food-gathering game showing why systems with more variety recover better.
  • Community: acting out the "jobs" of different species, such as worms loosening soil or bees pollinating flowers.
  • Interrelationships: a game where campers playing predators compete to catch a limited number of prey.
  • Change: a hands-on activity showing how rock weathers into soil over time.
  • Adaptation: wearing masks with different beak shapes to see which can reach nectar in a large flower.

Every day, campers also spent quiet time alone outdoors at their "Magic Spot" to reflect and observe nature. In a group event called the Sunship Convention, they chose actions to take for the environment. Swimming, canoeing and campfires filled the rest of the day.

In July 2015, 23 campers volunteered for the study: 13 boys and 10 girls, most aged 11. On the first and last days of the program, they did two things:

  • A 14-question multiple-choice quiz, with two questions on each of the seven ideas.
  • Open questions, read aloud, which they answered in words, drawings or both, with captions explaining their pictures. The questions asked about favorite activities, favorite places to learn, feelings about nature, actions they could take, and how important helping nature was to them.

The researchers had tested the questions beforehand with children aged 10 to 14. They organized results into three areas: knowledge, feelings and actions.

What they found
The main finding is that, seen through campers' own eyes, the camp gave children meaningful learning in all three areas. The open questions also revealed learning a quiz alone would not have caught.

  1. Knowledge grew, but unevenly. Average quiz scores rose from about 11 to about 12.5 out of 14.
    • Clear gains: cycles, interrelationships and adaptation. Adaptation was the least understood idea before camp, and scores on it nearly doubled.
    • No clear change: energy flow, community and change. Most of these were already well understood before camp, which the researchers think reflects what children had learned at school.
    • Still hardest: diversity, which remained the least understood idea after camp.
  2. Hands-on, social lessons were campers' favorite experiences. Asked about their favorite activities, campers named the lessons on how nature works, not swimming, canoeing, meals or free time. One favorite was learning about photosynthesis outdoors with a giant leaf prop. Others were looking for decomposers and acting out a food chain. Campers valued team games and learning from counselors and each other. They said they felt happy, calm and interested while learning.
  3. Children's sense of where learning happens broadened. Before camp, children saw the classroom as the normal place to learn. One even wrote it was the only place children could learn. Several drew it as dull, with students sitting at desks. After camp, all but one camper preferred learning outdoors. Their drawings showed children standing outside with props and smiling. They described the forest as quiet enough to concentrate and as a place to see topics, such as decomposition, firsthand.
  4. Care for nature deepened. Campers linked nature at camp with happiness, interest, awe and excitement. After camp, more drawings and answers showed a wish to protect habitats and care for plants and animals. One camper described feeling empowered to use what she had learned at camp to make a difference. The researchers note that the new setting, fun and friends also played a part. They see these hopeful feelings as important because children often feel powerless about big environmental problems.
  5. Ideas for helping nature broadened. Before camp, most answers were about planting trees, cutting fewer trees, recycling, driving less or picking up litter. After camp, about six in ten campers named a new action. These included making habitat for wildlife, buying organic food, protecting small plants and sharing what they knew with their families. For example, campers planned to teach parents to sort waste or encourage them to drive less. Nearly all campers already rated helping nature as "very important" before camp, so that rating changed little.

What this means for your practice

  • Make concept lessons active and social. Campers chose the hands-on concept lessons over free time and swimming. Props, role-play and team games let children act out ideas like food chains and adaptation.
  • Teach a topic where it happens. Children valued seeing decomposition and photosynthesis in the forest itself, and came to see the outdoors as a real place to learn. Where you can, take each lesson to the place it is about.
  • Ask open questions and invite drawings. The quiz showed knowledge gains, but the open questions and drawings showed changes in feelings, actions and where children think learning happens. The researchers highlight this approach as a way to catch unplanned learning. Try a simple before-and-after drawing prompt with captions.
  • Strengthen the ideas that didn't move. The researchers recommend more emphasis on diversity, energy flow, community and change, which did not show clear gains. At the end of your own program, check which key ideas children still find hard.
  • Connect nature to wider issues. The researchers recommend helping campers see how ecological ideas relate to broader issues in society.
  • Give children a way to take action home. After camp, campers came up with family actions such as teaching parents to sort waste. Sunship Earth's Convention, where campers choose actions to take, is one example of how a program builds this in. The study did not test the Convention on its own.

RETURN TO RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION 

The Bottom Line

The researchers surveyed 23 campers, mostly aged 11, on the first and last days of a residential nature camp, using a short quiz plus open questions children answered in words and drawings. Their main argument is that listening to children's own views shows the camp offered meaningful learning in knowledge, feelings and actions. It also shows things a quiz alone would miss. Campers' understanding of key ecological ideas rose overall, though some ideas improved much more than others. The children's favorite experiences were the hands-on lessons about how nature works, ahead of swimming or free time. They came to see the forest, not only the classroom, as a good place to learn. They also expressed more care for nature and named a wider range of ways to help, including teaching their families. For educators, the study points to active, social, outdoor lessons, and to open questions and drawings as ways to see what children really took away.