Why this matters and the context
Children who feel connected to nature are more likely to act in environmentally responsible ways. Playing outdoors is also good for children's development. Yet many children now spend more time indoors than out. Residential programs give children several days to learn about nature while living in it, with free time to explore. But simply putting children in nature does not always build a connection. Few studies check whether a residential program really changes how connected children feel or how much they play outside. The researchers set out to evaluate one program on exactly these goals. The program's coordinators, teachers and school leaders helped decide what to measure.
What the researchers did
The Shaver's Creek Outdoor School is run by staff of the Shaver's Creek Environmental Center in central Pennsylvania. It is a four-day, three-night program in a camp setting. Its goal is to teach children, through hands-on experience, how the natural world and the human-built world connect.
- The daily rhythm: a typical day has a morning lesson, lunch, an afternoon lesson, free time to explore the grounds before dinner, and campfire activities. Lessons happen outdoors, rain or shine.
- Lesson topics: water and nutrient cycles, natural resources, animal adaptations, ancient and modern ecosystems, and how people lived in the 1800s compared with today.
- Activities: a Web of Life game showing how species depend on each other and on resources; a stream study looking at creatures whose presence shows how healthy the water is; and a pretend public meeting where students speak as people and as animals or plants.
- Life at camp: meals aim to be waste free, so students see how their actions affect natural systems. Students also do team-building games and community meetings. They sleep in cabins with a counselor. For some, it is their first time away from home.
In spring 2010, the researchers surveyed two groups:
- Attenders: 156 fifth graders from three schools in Mifflin County, Pennsylvania, which had sent students to the program for years. They were surveyed four days before the program and three weeks after.
- A comparison group: 72 fifth graders from nearby counties with similar backgrounds, who did not attend, surveyed at the same times.
The survey asked children to agree or disagree with statements on a seven-point scale. It covered four things:
- Nature connection: a feeling of oneness with nature. The questions were adapted from an adult survey to a fifth-grade reading level and tested with 12 students first.
- Affinity for nature: good feelings in nature, such as attraction, freedom and comfort.
- Attitudes to outdoor play: for example, "I'd rather play outside than inside" and "I'd rather play video games than play outside."
- Outdoor play: what children did in the past week, for example "I played outside with my friends" and "I explored in a natural area."
What they found
The main finding is that children who attended felt more connected to nature and played outside more afterward, while children who didn't attend did not change.
- Children who attended felt more connected to nature. Their nature connection scores rose from about 5.8 to about 6.0 out of 7 between the survey before and the one three weeks after. The comparison group's scores did not change. The rise was modest, but the researchers see it as one of the program's most important effects, because nature connection is linked to caring for the environment.
- Children who attended played outside more. Their reports of outdoor play in the past week rose from about 5.6 to about 6.0 out of 7. The comparison group showed no significant change. The researchers note that the program keeps children outdoors in all weather, which may help them feel fewer limits on going outside at home.
- Liking for nature and attitudes to outdoor play did not change for attenders. Attenders started out higher than the comparison group on both. Their liking for nature was already about 6.4 out of 7, which the researchers say left little room to grow. The comparison group's attitude to outdoor play did rise. The researchers suggest summer vacation coming up may explain this.
The researchers could not tell which parts of the program caused these changes. Based on what the program offers, they point to three things:
- built-in free time to play outdoors
- personal mentoring by staff
- spending several nights outdoors
They also think recruiting students who live near the camp may help, because children recognize the same natural features in their own backyards.
What this means for your practice
- Protect unstructured time outdoors. The researchers point to built-in free play as one likely reason children connected with nature and played outside more. Resist filling every hour with lessons.
- Use staff as mentors. Counselors lived with students and gave them personal attention. The researchers name this mentoring as another likely contributor.
- Give children more than one night. The researchers also name spending several nights outdoors as a possible ingredient.
- Connect to places children know. Most attenders lived in the same region as the camp. The researchers suggest this helped children see nature as part of their own surroundings. Point out features children can also find near home.
- Add activities that build feelings for nature. Many of the program's activities, such as Web of Life and the stream study, build empathy for living things. The researchers recommend exploring these further and adding activities that strengthen emotional ties to nature.
- Measure what you aim to change. The researchers argue that evaluation should match a program's goals. If nature connection and outdoor play are your goals, survey them before and after. Expect little change on anything children already rate very highly.
RETURN TO RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION
The Bottom Line
The researchers surveyed 156 fifth graders before and after a residential outdoor school and compared them with 72 similar fifth graders who did not attend. Their main argument is that a residential program can strengthen children's connection to nature and get them playing outside more. Three weeks after the program, children who attended felt more at one with nature and reported more outdoor play and exploring than before. Children who didn't attend showed no change on either. The program did not raise attenders' liking for nature or their preference for playing outside, but both were already near the top of the scale beforehand. For educators, the study suggests that a few days of living, learning and playing outdoors can deepen children's bond with nature. It also shows that programs should measure the outcomes they actually aim for.