Children are among the people most at risk when disasters strike. The World Health Organization estimates that children account for 30% to 50% of all deaths from natural disasters. Children spend about a third of their waking hours at school, and many schools in developing countries sit in hazard-prone areas. In 2019, for example, Cyclone Idai damaged schools in Zimbabwe and killed students and teachers. The Sendai Framework, a UN agreement setting global priorities for reducing disaster risk from 2015 to 2030, calls on countries to build disaster education into schools. Researchers increasingly see children not only as needing protection, but as able to keep themselves safe and pass what they learn on to their families. The researchers wanted to know how schools in developing countries actually teach disaster preparedness, and what holds them back.
The researchers reviewed 38 studies published between 2015 and 2024 about disaster education in primary and secondary schools in developing countries. The countries included Indonesia, Ghana, Iran, Pakistan, the Philippines, China, Vietnam, Lebanon, Botswana, Malaysia and Dominica. For each study, they recorded:
- how disaster topics were built into the curriculum;
- which subjects carried them;
- which activities outside lessons schools used;
- what challenges schools faced.
They also checked each subject and activity against a framework of five kinds of disaster learning:
- Knowledge: understanding how hazards such as tsunamis, cyclones and volcanic eruptions work.
- Response: staying safe, for example knowing warning signs, evacuating or sheltering, doing drills, giving basic first aid and staying safe after a hazard passes.
- Action: taking steps to reduce risk, by working out what makes people vulnerable and what strengthens their ability to cope.
- Participation: working with the community to identify threats, plan how to become more resilient and carry out those plans.
- Integration: making the whole school a safe, prepared place, through safe buildings, school emergency plans and policies.
What the researchers found:
- The main finding is that lessons cover knowledge and response, but rarely action, participation or integration. Across the 16 school subjects that carried disaster topics:
- all 16 covered knowledge;
- 13 covered response;
- 7 covered action;
- only geography touched on integration;
- none included participation.
- The researchers call knowledge and response "lower-order" aims. They argue that students may learn how hazards work and how to stay safe, but get few chances to practice reducing risk or to turn what they know into community action. As a result, the school does not become a place where the whole community learns about disaster risk.
- Activities outside lessons are where students take part. Every one of the nine kinds of activity outside lessons involved students in participation.
- Safety drills were the most common activity, appearing in 14 studies, and the only common one that touched all five kinds of learning.
- Risk mapping, where students identify and map hazards around their school or community, also covered all five.
- First aid and psychosocial training (help with the emotional effects of disasters) covered participation, response and action.
- Other activities included special disaster awareness days, school assemblies, school clubs, competitions, training student "champions" and, in Indonesia, planting mangroves (coastal trees that protect shorelines).
- The researchers note that these activities mostly prepare students for emergencies rather than reducing risk in the long term, and that few schools use risk mapping or mangrove planting. They describe a split between what is taught in class and what students practice outside it.
- Most countries weave disaster topics into existing subjects. Twenty-two studies described this approach. Other approaches included:
- adding disaster units or chapters, as in Ghana, Indonesia and Lebanon, where final-year earth science classes include a unit on hazards;
- safety and disaster modules, as in China, Samoa and Indonesia;
- folding disaster topics into civic or citizenship education, ethics or defense studies.
- The Philippines was the only country to teach disaster risk reduction as a separate subject, in senior high school, because of its frequent typhoons, floods, landslides and earthquakes. Indonesia used four different approaches, more than any other country. The researchers warn that spreading topics across many subjects does not by itself make a coherent program, and can leave students to make the links on their own.
- Geography is the main home for disaster learning, but some countries go much wider. Geography carried disaster topics in eight countries, followed by social studies in five and science in four. Ghana included disaster topics in 12 subjects, Iran in 10 and Indonesia in 9. These included subjects not usually linked to disasters, such as religion, language and culture, math, history and creative arts. The researchers see geography as a natural fit, because disasters are closely tied to where they happen. They argue that teaching disasters through social and cultural subjects also shows that disasters are shaped by people's beliefs, institutions and everyday behavior, not only by nature.
- Schools face common barriers.
- Lack of funding was the most widespread, reported in eight countries.
- Six countries did not cover all the hazards their area faces.
- Other barriers included too little teacher training, no clear policy on disaster education, crowded timetables with little time for disaster topics, and textbooks focused narrowly on facts.
- The researchers identify the lack of supportive policy as the common thread. They note that many countries added disaster content to the curriculum without training the teachers who must teach it.
What this means for your practice:
- Link classroom learning to action in the community. Lessons rarely went beyond knowing and responding, while students' participation happened outside lessons. The researchers recommend partnerships with disaster agencies, local communities and humanitarian organizations, so students learn "with," "from" and "in" their communities. For example, follow a lesson on how floods work with a project mapping flood risks in the neighborhood.
- Make drills a full learning experience. Drills were the only common activity that touched all five kinds of learning. Use them to discuss why each step matters, what could go better and what would make your site safer, not just to practice leaving the building.
- Try risk mapping. Like drills, risk mapping covered all five kinds of learning, yet few schools used it. Students identify the hazards around their school or site and think about what could reduce them.
- Include first aid and coping skills. First aid and psychosocial training were among the most common activities outside lessons. The researchers note that disasters can leave children anxious, and that coping skills help them manage stress and recover.
- Connect the pieces across subjects. The researchers warn that disaster topics spread across subjects can stay disconnected. If you teach one piece, link it to what students learn elsewhere, or plan a shared unit with colleagues.
- Cover all the hazards your learners face. Six countries covered only some of their hazards. Check that your teaching reflects the full range of local risks.
- Plan around clear learning goals. The researchers recommend choosing teaching methods and activities based on agreed learning goals for knowledge, skills and attitudes, so that all five kinds of disaster learning are covered.
RETURN TO RISK AND ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION
The Bottom Line
The researchers reviewed 38 studies of disaster education in primary and secondary schools in developing countries. Their main argument is that schools mostly teach students about hazards and how to respond in an emergency, but rarely help them take action to reduce risk or work with their communities. As a result, students are not yet becoming the active "change agents" that disaster education aims for. Most schools weave disaster topics into existing subjects, especially geography. Lessons focus on how hazards work and on safety steps such as evacuating or giving first aid. Hands-on involvement happens mainly outside lessons, through drills and mapping local risks. Too little funding, limited teacher training, unclear policies and crowded timetables hold schools back. The researchers call for redesigning disaster education to cover all five kinds of disaster learning, backed by clear policies and community partnerships, so that students can put what they learn into practice.