The impact of place-based education on middle school students' environmental literacy and stewardship

Hamilton, Erica, & Marckini-Polk, Lisa. (2023). The impact of place-based education on middle school students’ environmental literacy and stewardship. Cogent Education, 10(1), 2163789+. 10.1080/2331186X.2022.2163789

Place-based projects ask a lot of teachers, who often find partners, secure permissions and plan field trips alone. When time and energy are stretched, which parts of a project matter most for students? And what gets in the way?

The researchers followed two experienced teachers and their 226 middle school students in the Midwestern United States through the 2018–19 school year. Each teacher ran a“meaningful watershed educational experience”: an outdoor investigation of a local water issue, linked to classroom learning and ending in a stewardship project, in which students take action to care for or improve the local environment. Before and after, students took a Great Lakes knowledge test, wrote about how people harm wildlife habitat, and completed a survey on their feelings toward nature, attachment to their community, everyday environmental habits and confidence to act.

Teachers also rated their projects against ten guiding principles for place-based stewardship education, set out by the regional program that supported them. In short, a strong project: 

1. Is rooted in the places where students live and play 

2. Shows how people and the environment affect each other 

3. Uses hands-on inquiry built into school learning 

4. Builds partnerships that benefit school and community 

5. Runs over weeks or months 

6. Delivers real local benefits 

7. Gives students a voice in decisions 

8. Explores different viewpoints 

9. Helps students explore their own values 

10. Involves students in public discussion.

Both classes chose to focus on damage to wildlife habitat, one of four threats to the Great Lakes that the program set out.

In an urban school, a 7th-grade science class ran a “Suitable Salmon Habitat Study.” Students raised young salmon in a classroom fish tank and learned how pollution washing off the land can harm the health of a watershed. They tested the water at five local streams, judged which was healthiest, and released their salmon there. Along the way they worked with five community partners, including the state natural resources department and a local group of creek stewards.

In a suburban school, a 7th- and 8th-grade class ran a project called “Good Practices Make Good Neighbors,” learning why native plants matter and how invasive plants harm the watershed. Students followed rainwater runoff from a pond on the school grounds to a nearby neighborhood lake, and helped a lakeside homeowner check the water’s health and plan ways to protect it. They also tackled garlic mustard, an invasive plant growing around the school and neighborhood. Students pulled up 90 bags of it from a neighborhood common area, a bike path and the school grounds. They taught the rest of their school how to remove it, and mailed a student-made flyer about it to 253 local homes.

The researchers found: 

1. Having a say and seeing results went with growth in care for the environment. This is the study’s central finding. At the end, students rated whether they “got to make some choices about what to do and how to do it,” and whether they saw their work “protect or improve the environment.” Students who agreed with either statement scored higher at the end of the year than at the start on most survey measures. Students who disagreed mostly scored lower at the end than at the start. The researchers conclude that the strongest projects give students a real say and make their impact clear. 

2. Giving students a voice was what teachers were least able to achieve. Teachers rated themselves strongest on partnerships, project length and local benefits (principles 4 to 6). They rated themselves weakest on the four principles about students’ own voice and participation (7 to 10), the same things that went with growth in finding 1. The urban class, for example, made posters to tell the community about its project, but they were never put up, and students had no chance to talk with community leaders. Part of the reason was the grant itself: to get funding, teachers had to fix the project’s focus before students could have a say. 

3. Teachers carried the projects largely alone. Each was the only teacher in their school running such a project, and did most of the planning, logistics and paperwork. Support from school leaders shaped what they felt able to do. Events outside their control added to the strain: record snowfall cut outdoor time, and a neighborhood association withdrew access to the lake the suburban class planned to study, citing worries about liability. The researchers stress that teachers newer to this work would need more support. 

4. Test scores rose only a little, but teachers saw more learning. Knowledge test scores rose about 5%, and the written answers and survey showed no real change across all students. Teachers felt students learned more than the tests showed, judging by their questions, discussions and engagement in the field.

What this means for your practice: 

- Build in real choice, even when the topic is set. Choice went with growth, but a fixed topic squeezed it out. The researchers suggest explaining to students how and why the topic was chosen, then inviting them to help reach the goal. Tell students when they are making a choice. 

- Make the impact visible. The researchers recommend drawing a clear link between each task and what it improves locally. 

- Check your plans against the ten principles. These teachers’ ratings showed where their projects were strong and where students’ voice was missing. Pay special attention to principles 7 to 10, such as deciding early when students will discuss their work with community members. The study used the principles to rate projects; it did not test them. 

- Use more than one way to see learning. A single test missed much of what teachers saw. The researchers recommend several measures across a project, such as listening to discussions. 

- If you run or fund programs, back the teachers. The researchers recommend helping teachers win support from school leaders and staying flexible when plans fall through. Teachers felt they were expected to come up with a new project every year, which made it hard to refine their approach, and asked for the freedom to build on an established project instead.

RETURN TO THE PLACE-BASED EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION 

The Bottom Line

The researchers followed two experienced teachers and 226 middle school students through a year of local watershed projects. Their main message is that place-based projects build students' care for their community and environment most when students have a real say and can see the difference their work makes. Students who felt they had choices, or saw their work help the environment, scored higher by the end of the year on care for nature, attachment to their community and confidence to act. Students who did not mostly scored lower than at the start. Yet giving students a say was what teachers were least able to achieve: rating their projects against ten principles of good place-based teaching, they scored themselves lowest on student voice and public discussion. Part of the reason was that the grant required teachers to fix each project's topic in advance, and each teacher was running their project largely alone. For educators, the study points to building in choice and visible impact from the start. For programs and school leaders, it shows how much teachers need support.