Some risks are hard to teach because people feel safe. A quarter of the Netherlands lies below sea level, and about two-thirds of the country would flood often without its dikes, the raised banks built to hold back water. Yet many Dutch people assume the authorities have flooding fully under control. One Dutch study calls this "the myth of dry feet." The research team's own earlier studies found that students:
- knew flooding was a risk for the country, but saw little risk where they lived;
- felt little fear about flooding;
- knew little about their local flood defenses;
- trusted those defenses almost blindly.
Geography is a required subject in the first three years of Dutch secondary school, so the researchers saw it as the natural place to change this. Because flood risks differ greatly from region to region, they built the program around one region, West-Friesland, in the province of North Holland. They used information from the regional water board, the local authority responsible for flood safety.
The researchers developed the program in rounds, drafting, testing and revising it each time. Seven geography teachers from schools in and near the region and four geography teacher educators reviewed each draft. Each person first listed its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats, then the group discussed them. Finally, two geography teachers used the lessons with one class each of 15-year-olds in academic tracks. The materials include a course book with assignments, a teacher's guide with slides, an online game and an online flood simulation. This article describes the design and teachers' views; the effect on students was to be tested in a later study.
The designers saw learning about a risk as three steps, each with its own obstacle:
- Understanding how floods happen and how they are managed. Obstacles include how hard floods are to imagine, misconceptions, and people's habit of looking for evidence that supports what they already believe.
- Seeing flooding as a real risk to yourself. The obstacle is optimism, the belief that bad things happen to other people.
- Intending to prepare. The obstacle is denial: when fear is too strong, people push the threat away instead of acting.
To get past these obstacles, the program combines quick, feeling-based reactions with slower, careful analysis. Vivid local information, such as watching a dike break in a simulation, prompts students to look closely. Understanding the local situation then stirs feelings that motivate them to weigh the threat and their options. The aim is moderate concern: enough to engage students, but not so much that they shut down.
What the researchers found:
- The main outcome is a program that turns vivid local flood information into moderate concern, balanced with ways to cope. Three design ideas emerged over the rounds of review to describe how it works:
- Feelings: attaching feelings to mental images of familiar places, such as a local dike or street.
- Picturing: making flooding easy to bring to mind, imagine and understand in the local setting.
- Blending: mixing many teaching methods, so that students both experience and analyze flood risk.
- These replaced the designers' first, more general ideas about motivating students and connecting them to their surroundings.
- The lessons follow the chain of events in a flood, then turn to coping.
- Lesson 1 covers when high water becomes a threat, how dikes fail, and floods in the area's past.
- Lesson 2 covers a flood's effects: how far and how deep the water would spread, casualties and costs.
- Lesson 3 explores what family and friends think about flood risk.
- Lesson 4 covers the water board's work on preventing floods, reducing damage and handling emergencies. It includes which local dikes fall short of safety standards and how little the authorities can help once a flood happens.
- Lessons 5 to 7 are group projects on what residents themselves can do, such as deciding whether to evacuate or move to an upper floor.
- About half the content is about coping, so that students do not respond with denial.
- Students do most of the work through active tasks, each with a clear purpose.
- Levee Patroller, a 3D video game, puts students in the role of a dike inspector checking for weak spots during high water. If they miss them, the dike breaks. It makes dike failure easy to imagine and draws students in.
- A flood simulation of the school's own area, built with water board data, lets students choose where a dike breaks. It shows how far the water spreads, how deep it gets (including at their homes and school), and the casualties and costs.
- Interviews with relatives and friends about flood risk and preparedness get students explaining what they have learned and responding to others' views.
- Fieldwork has students observe a short stretch of a nearby dike and judge its strength. This connects real dikes, ditches and water levels to what they saw in the game and simulation.
- Group projects on prevention and preparedness end in presentations meant to persuade others to prepare.
- Reviewers praised the design and pushed for more on feelings and coping. They liked the consistency of the lessons, the variety of methods, the problem-solving focus and the simulation. Early reviewers asked for a bigger role for feelings and more student-led work on coping. Teachers reviewing the first draft also raised concerns about how clear the simulation was, chances for students to reflect and time. The designers added reflection assignments and group projects.
- The classroom trial showed practical lessons. Both trial teachers found the material very useful and were extremely enthusiastic about the flood simulation. Students needed clearer instructions before the simulation and more time to reflect afterward. The fieldwork, set as homework, got less effort than expected because it clashed with assignments in other subjects. The researchers conclude that this kind of program has to be coordinated with the rest of the school. The teachers were convinced that vivid local flood information, combined with ways to cope, could change students' thinking without causing panic.
- Local agencies backed the program. The water board and the national ministry for infrastructure and environment were pleased enough to sponsor an online version.
What this means for your practice:
These ideas come from a carefully tested design and from teachers' feedback; the program's effect on students had not yet been measured.
- Make the risk local and personal. The whole program is built around students' own surroundings, and the simulation showing water depth at their homes and school was the teachers' favorite feature. For any hazard your learners think is "solved," local maps, agency data or a scenario set at your own site can do the same job.
- Pair every threat with what can be done. The designers gave about half the content to prevention and preparedness, to avoid fear tipping into denial. When you show a vivid risk, follow it quickly with actions people and agencies can take.
- Follow experience with analysis. The program pairs immersive tasks, such as the game and simulation, with analysis, discussion and reflection. After a vivid activity, ask learners to explain what happened and why.
- Prepare students for simulations, then debrief. In the trial, students needed clearer instructions beforehand and time to reflect afterward. Build both into your timing.
- Get learners talking with family. Interviewing relatives about flooding was designed to get students putting ideas into words and hearing other views. This adapts easily to family programs and take-home tasks.
- Link the screen to the real landscape, and check the timing. The dike fieldwork connected the game and simulation to real places. In the trial it suffered from clashing homework, so plan field tasks around the school calendar.
- Work with the agency in charge. The water board supplied the simulation data and later helped fund an online version. Local agencies can offer data, sites and credibility.
RETURN TO RISK AND ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION
The Bottom Line
The researchers designed a seven-lesson flood-risk program for 15-year-olds, revised it using feedback from geography teachers and teacher educators, and tried it in two classes. Their main argument is that shaking students out of the belief that flooding "won't happen here" requires three things. The program must make flooding vivid and local, stir moderate concern, and always pair the threat with what people can do. Students play a video game in which they hunt for weak spots in a dike, and run a simulation showing how deep floodwater would get at their own homes and school. They also observe a nearby dike, talk with family about flooding and work on group projects about preparing. Three design ideas sum up the approach: linking feelings to familiar places, making flooding easy to picture, and mixing many teaching methods. Teachers found the program inspiring and were convinced it could change students' thinking without causing panic.