Students' perceptions of the residential environmental education program at the New Jersey School of Conservation

Smith-Sebasto, N. J., & Obenchain, Victoria L. (2009). Students’ perceptions of the residential environmental education program at the New Jersey School of Conservation. Journal of Environmental Education, 40, 50-62.

Why this matters and the context
Every year, many schools send students to residential centers for a few nights of outdoor learning. Educators often judge these trips by what students say as they board the bus home. But does that last-day view still hold months later? An earlier study at the same center asked students what they thought only on the day they left. In this study, the researchers asked the same questions of the same school district's students. Then they asked again six months later, back at school, to see whether students' views had shifted.

What the researchers did
The New Jersey School of Conservation is a residential center in northwest New Jersey run by a university. The school district in this study had sent its sixth graders there for nearly 40 years, and the program had not changed for at least 15. Every student took part in the same seven sessions:

  • Team challenges: group problem-solving activities designed to build teamwork, trust and confidence.
  • Sensory Awareness in Nature: a session exploring nature through the senses, which included crossing a high cable bridge.
  • Two ecology sessions: Eco-Discovery and Web of Life.
  • A climbing wall or confidence course.
  • One science session: Black Bear Ecology, bird study or stream study.
  • One extra session: such as archery, orienteering (finding your way with a map and compass), early American woodworking or survival skills.

Teachers from the visiting school taught most sessions, using the center's lesson plans. High school students who had attended as sixth graders slept in the cabins and guided students between sessions.

In autumn 2005, 336 sixth graders from three schools in the district attended. Just before boarding the bus home, each wrote short answers to three questions:

  • What was the most meaningful thing you learned?
  • What was most confusing, and what do you still not understand?
  • What would you like to learn more about?

Six months later, the same students answered the same questions in class. The researchers sorted the answers into five groups:

  • Social: teamwork, trust and confidence.
  • Safety: skills for staying safe outdoors.
  • Science: ecology, science and local history.
  • Recreation: activities enjoyed for fun.
  • The trip itself: schedules, rules and free time.

What they found
The main finding is that what students found meaningful changed over six months, while what confused them stayed much the same.

  1. What students valued most shifted from social and safety lessons to science.
    • On the last day: about a third of students named a social lesson, such as overcoming a fear of heights on the climbing wall or learning to trust teammates. Safety came next, mostly what to do around bears and how to use a compass.
    • Six months later: science answers had risen from about a quarter to about two in five students. Examples were learning to test water quality and what animals need to survive. Social answers had dropped to about one in five.
    • The researchers' explanation: teamwork felt most important while students were still living in groups that depended on it. Science grew in meaning as students had time to reflect, and perhaps as their teachers built on the center's lessons in class. The study did not test this. The researchers also stress that one in five students still named social lessons, so many were still drawing on them.
  2. Science content was the most confusing part of the trip, and it stayed that way. About four in ten students named a science topic as most confusing, both on the last day and six months later. Examples were the test tubes in the water testing session and where bears make their dens. The researchers note that students this age can struggle with ideas that involve several factors at once. In the water session, for example, pollution, plants, temperature and nutrients all affect stream water. Without clear explanation, that can lead to confusion and misunderstandings.
  3. Orienteering caused confusion that lasted. Most of the confusion about safety skills was about using a compass in the orienteering session. Six months later, 40 of the 42 safety answers were still about orienteering. The researchers conclude that the two-hour session was not long enough to learn the skill.
  4. Confusion about logistics and rules lasted too. About one in five students were confused by practical matters on the last day. They didn't know where to go when they got off the bus or where things were. They didn't understand why they were placed in certain groups, why they couldn't bring electronics, or why they couldn't sit with friends at meals. Six months later, these were still the second most common answers. The researchers suggest that in a new place, students rely on adults for direction, and unexplained procedures leave them unsettled.
  5. Unclear teaching left students confused months later. About one in ten students said an instructor was hard to understand, gave unclear directions, used unfamiliar words or didn't explain why they were doing an activity. This rose slightly at six months. The researchers link it to how the sessions were staffed. Visiting teachers often watched a session only once or twice before teaching it, and then taught it several times a day.
  6. Students wanted more science, and kept wanting it. About three in four students wanted to learn more about science topics, such as animals, water creatures or local history. This barely changed in six months. Many of these answers used words like "fun," "cool" and "favorite." The researchers conclude that students want to learn more about what they enjoyed.

What this means for your practice

  • Plan for learning that continues after the trip. Science became more meaningful to students in the months after they went home. The researchers think reflection and classroom follow-up helped, though they did not test this. Classroom teachers can plan lessons that return to the center's topics. Centers can give visiting teachers ideas and materials for follow-up.
  • Treat teamwork and confidence as real outcomes. Students valued these most as they left, and one in five still did six months later. Tell students these are goals of the trip, so they recognize what they have gained.
  • Prepare students for the practical side. Confusion about where to go and why lasted for months. The researchers suggest starting with a quick walking tour, introducing the sessions in class before the trip, and giving students a schedule. They say this lets students worry less about logistics and focus on the sessions.
  • Give hard skills more time. The two-hour orienteering session was not enough for many students. The researchers suggest teaching the parts of a compass before the trip or practicing afterward at school. Look for skills in your own program that might need the same.
  • Make the purpose and the steps clear. Science and instructions were the main sources of lasting confusion. The researchers suggest giving clear objectives before each activity and inviting students to ask questions as soon as they are confused.
  • Help visiting teachers prepare. The researchers suggest pre-trip workshops for visiting teachers, sending lesson plans in advance, and giving them a center educator to contact with questions.
  • Build on what students enjoyed. Students wanted to learn more about the topics they had fun with. Their answers to "What would you like to learn more about?" can guide follow-up lessons.

RETURN TO RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION EERESEARCH COLLECTION 

The Bottom Line

The researchers asked 336 sixth graders three short written questions as they left a residential center and again six months later at school. Their main finding is that students' views of the trip changed over time. Leaving the center, students most often named lessons about teamwork, confidence and staying safe outdoors as the most meaningful, such as what to do if they met a bear. Six months later, science and nature topics had become the most meaningful. Other things stayed the same. Science content remained the most confusing part of the trip. Confusion about schedules, rules and unclear explanations was still there months later. Most students kept wanting to learn more science. For educators, this shows that learning from a residential trip keeps developing after students go home. Preparing students beforehand, supporting the people who teach, and following up afterward all help the trip count for more.