Farm and garden programs can make science real for students. But students from low-income neighborhoods often have the least chance to take part. Research has mostly looked at this from the side of schools and teachers. What do the community educators who run these programs do to connect with neighborhoods and open their doors wider, and what holds them back?
In fall 2020, early in the COVID-19 pandemic, the researchers interviewed 21 educators and managers from nine Bay Area nonprofits. The programs range from field trips and after-school classes to paid internships for teens. Some organizations serve particular low-income neighborhoods in Oakland, San Francisco and San José. Others, based on farms and ranches outside the cities, serve schools across the region. The researchers asked two questions: how do programs use local places to link students and community, and how do they tackle barriers that keep students out?
Connecting students and community
1. Shared spaces were the natural meeting point. Community gardens, farm events and farmers markets gave students and neighbors reasons to work side by side. In one San Francisco community garden, older gardeners kept the space safe because they knew children used it. As one educator put it, “the kids really look out for the garden and the community looks out for the kids.”
2. Local knowledge made the place students’ own. One educator opened lessons by asking what plant, tea or food someone had given students when they were sick, and also treated elders and students as equally valuable sources of knowledge. Students interviewed family members and heard from guest speakers. Several organizations grew crops local families eat, such as collard greens, which educators said sparked conversations about food and how different cultures cook the same crop. Indigenous knowledge came in through partnerships: one organization’s educators were trained by a local tribal community in community activities, such as holding community meetings, building shelters and gathering food.
3. Neighborhood-based organizations went furthest. Small organizations serving their own neighborhood wove local culture and traditions into lessons and acted on community feedback, for example by growing requested crops and running programs in local languages. Larger organizations serving the whole region focused mainly on lessons about Indigenous peoples, rather than drawing on the cultures and traditions of the families they served.
Opening the doors
4. Practical support lowered barriers of cost, travel and language. All nine organizations relied on grants. Three offered some programs free, and five used sliding-scale fees, so schools with more students eligible for free or reduced-price lunch paid less. One organization gave high-need schools about $500 each toward a bus; city organizations bought transit cards, and one ran a “walking school bus,” with staff walking students from school to the farm. Seven organizations translated materials into the main local languages, and two supported deaf students with sign language interpreters and captions. The researchers note that translated materials, and staff who share students’ languages and backgrounds, show students that their culture matters.
5. The organizations’ own limits were also a barrier. This is the study’s new contribution: earlier research mostly blamed schools for gaps in access. However, small staff sizes meant each community organization could serve only a set number of schools, and outreach to new schools slowed or stopped, especially during the pandemic. Few organizations tracked which schools they reached or missed.
What this means for your practice:
- Invite home knowledge. Open with a question about family remedies or foods, as one educator did, and invite family members in as guest speakers.
- Ask the community what to grow and teach. Neighborhood-based organizations went furthest by acting on community feedback. Ask families what they cook at home, and plant some of it.
- Use shared spaces. Community gardens and farmers markets were where students and neighbors met most naturally. Partner with a community garden or farmers market so students learn alongside neighbors.
- Plan access as carefully as lessons. These were the main ways the organizations lowered barriers of cost, travel and language: use sliding-scale fees, find funding for buses or transit passes, translate materials, and hire staff who share students’ languages.
- Track who you reach. Because few organizations knew which schools they were missing, the researchers recommend mapping which schools and neighborhoods take part and which do not.
- Build networks to stretch capacity. Because small staff numbers limited how many schools each organization could serve, the researchers suggest groups of schools and organizations that meet through the year to share teacher training and reach new schools.
The Bottom Line
The researchers interviewed 21 educators and managers from nine Bay Area organizations that run farm and garden programs for schools. Their main message is that community organizations can be a strong bridge between schools and neighborhoods, but only if they plan deliberately for who can take part. Shared spaces such as community gardens brought students and neighbors together, and programs felt most local when they drew on families’ knowledge, foods and languages. Organizations lowered barriers of cost, travel and language through grants, sliding-scale fees, transportation help and translation. But the organizations’ own limits, especially limited staff, also kept schools out, and few tracked which schools they were missing. For educators, the study shows that who can take part needs as much planning as the lessons themselves.