Assessing the relationship between urban blue-green infrastructure and stress resilience in real settings: A systematic review

Li, L., & Lange, K. W. (2023). Assessing the relationship between urban blue-green infrastructure and stress resilience in real settings: A systematic review. Sustainability, 15(12). https://doi.org/10.3390/su15129240

Urban blue-green infrastructure can improve stress resilienceUrban environments can contribute to stress through various physical, social, and environmental factors, negatively affecting both physical and mental health. Integrating nature into public health strategies, particularly through exposure to urban green and blue spaces, offers a promising approach to enhancing well-being and creating healthier cities. To better understand the role of nature in urban stress reduction, this systematic review examined the existing evidence on the effects of urban landscapes and interventions on physiological and psychological stress.

A literature search was conducted to identify peer-reviewed studies published in English that examined the effects of urban landscape exposure on stress responses. The search focused on studies that measured biological indicators of physiological stress responses along with self-reported psychological indicators and scales that assessed mood, anxiety, distress, or perceived stress. A range of study designs were eligible for inclusion in the review, including randomized controlled trials (RCTs), non-RCTs, empirical studies, and mixed-methods studies. No age limits were placed on study participants. Only studies of outdoor landscape settings were included; however, studies examining the impact of viewing outdoor landscapes through windows were also considered. Nineteen studies, published in 22 articles, met these criteria and were included in the review. The majority of the studies were conducted in the U.S. and the U.K., with fewer in Germany, China, Japan, New Zealand, and Finland. The studies included four RCTs, four cross-sectional studies, and seven quasi-experimental studies. Participants ranged from 14 to 85 years (average 33 years) and included high school and university students, economically disadvantaged populations, gardeners, park visitors, and older adults. Nine studies compared naturalized landscapes with urban built environments, three examined the effects of green school or university campuses, five examined passive exposure to natural landscapes at home or work, and two focused on home or allotment gardens. Physiological assessments of stress mainly included salivary or hair cortisol levels (10 studies) and brain activity (7 studies), while one study examined skin conductance level and another examined cardiovascular measures. Measures of perceived psychological stress varied considerably across studies. Self-reported stress measures included the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS) and Perceived Stress Question (PSQ), as well as mood assessments.

Of the 19 reviewed studies, 15 found that passive sitting or light physical activity in urban green or blue spaces significantly reduced psychological and physical indicators of stress. Studies conducted with high school and college students were among those reporting positive findings. For instance, one randomized controlled experiment found that, compared with high school students in control conditions who had no view or viewed built settings, those with green window views showed reduced heart rate variability after a stress-inducing activity. This study suggests that classroom views of nature can improve recovery from stressful events. Additionally, four studies with university students reported improved physiological and psychological stress outcomes after visiting urban green spaces. In contrast, three studies reported no significant difference in physiological stress between adults who walked or sat in natural urban landscapes and control groups in built city settings. The review also found that most studies lacked objective measures of urban landscapes and often omitted key information about the landscape environment. This finding underscores the need for more comprehensive research methods that use objective measures of urban green infrastructure that incorporate factors such as the accessibility, availability, and biodiversity of urban green spaces.

Overall, the review findings suggest that exposure to urban blue-green infrastructure can reduce physiological and psychological stress responses across diverse populations. However, the lack of precise definitions and objective measures of landscape characteristics may limit the validity of these findings. The researchers therefore emphasize the need for objective, technology-based methods to assess how urban landscape types, quality, and patterns of human exposure influence stress recovery. The findings also highlight the importance of high-quality urban landscapes with well-planned green infrastructure that maintains sustainable ecological networks, supports biodiversity and species-rich habitats, and provides multifunctional spaces for observation and meditation, physical activity, and social interaction.

The Bottom Line

Urban blue-green infrastructure can improve stress resilience